Making preseason predictions is often an act in futility.
If you don’t believe me, look at my predictions for 2007…
And if you are still not convinced, look at my predictions for 2008…
And if that wasn’t enough, why not take a gander at my predictions last year…
But one thing that makes picks so worthless is of course the team that plays in April will inevitably be different that the team that plays in October. While midseason trades are usually all hype and not a lot of true impact, dealing for a true ace in midseason could be the difference between playing for a pennant or playing golf in October.
You just have to look at the Indians trading away their two Cy Young winners, Sabathia and Lee, to see how October can be affected by dealing an ace.
And for teams falling out of contention, trading away an ace could bring about much needed building blocks for the future.
Joe Carter, John Smoltz, Brady Anderson, Randy Johnson and Carlos Guillen, among others, were picked up by teams in mid season trades for pitching.
This year there are three legit aces… three difference making pitchers who are pitching for teams that are going nowhere.
One SHOULD be traded. One is ASKING to be traded. And one will INEVITABLY.
Let’s look at the one who SHOULD be traded first:
Santana was supposed to be for the Mets what Curt Schilling was to the Red Sox in 2004. With the Mets falling a Carlos Beltran called third strike short of the World Series in 2006 and the epic collapse of 2007… Omar Minaya needed to make a bold move.
And he did so bringing in the American League’s best pitcher to Queens. And you can’t blame Santana for the collapse of 2008! He won his last 7 decisions in ’08 including a complete game shutout on the second to last game of the season to keep hope alive in Flushing.
But the Mets aren’t an ace away from winning anymore. Their nice April not withstanding, they are a sinking team. Don’t believe me? On April 30th, the Mets were in first place, 5 games over .500. They are 6-14 since and their pitching staff and lineup are wearing down… and their farm system is notoriously bare.
Sure, Santana gives them a great arm every 5 days, but this team needs a shot in the arm and Santana’s trade value may never be this high. A little honesty in the Mets front office would have them admit they are not catching the Phillies (they are already a full week behind Philadelphia) and don’t have the horses to compete.
The team trading for Santana would have him for three more seasons… so the Mets could get as many as three pieces to a long term puzzle. Will they do it? Probably not. It’s the smart thing to do, which isn’t the Mets way of doing things.
Now for the one who is ASKING to be traded.
ROY OSWALT
I’ve been screaming for the Astros to trade Oswalt since the beginning of 2009. And with today’s news that Oswalt is waiving his no trade clause, it looks like it is going to happen.
This is his 10th season for the Astros and he was the MVP of the 2005 NLCS, the Astros lone trip to the World Series, so no doubt he has a lot of affection for Houston and the team.
But this team sucks. He knows it. We all know it. And while he is in the top 10 in the NL for ERA and WHIP, he is also second in the league in losses!
He has a 2-6 record. Only Charlie Morton (he with the 9.68 ERA) has more losses. Oswalt has pitched 6 innings in all 9 of his starts this year and has given the Astros 7 innings 6 times. He’s averaged 7 innings and about 2 1/2 runs a start for his last 5 starts… and has an 0-4 record to show for it.
Like the Mets, the Astros cupboard is bare on the farm and Oswalt should fetch at least 2 players ready to insert on the big league team.
Now the ace who will be INEVITABLY traded.
CLIFF LEE
Have the Mariners woken up (along with Ken Griffey Jr) from their first quarter nap?
10 days ago I said I wasn’t sure what the Mariners should do with their season. Cliff Lee won that day… then the Mariners lost 7 of their last 8 before winning 2 in a row.
They have Lee and Hernandez back, Griffey has some clutch hits and Milton Bradley is back from therapy… and they are still the third worst team in the American League.
There is a better chance that the Cubs will call to reacquire Bradley than Cliff Lee being a Mariner in 2011… and short of a massive winning streak, this Mariner team isn’t contending.
90 wins will probably win the West. The Mariners are on pace for 59. Forget .500, the Mariners are trying to reach .400 at this point.
They dealt away some good prospects to Philadelphia, Toronto, Oakland and I think Manchester United by the time the deal was done. It was a nice idea… but they need to think about 2011 now.
So think about the landscape of contenders now. You know two of these pitchers will be wearing new uniforms by the time October rolls around and possibly all three. And whatever contender picks them up will suddenly have a new potent weapon. A playoff contender could get over the hump, like the Brewers a few years ago when they picked up Sabathia.
A pennant contender could overcome their weaknesses with a new ace, like the Phillies last year with Cliff Lee.
Contenders like the Rangers, the Rays, the Cardinals, the Twins and the Tigers could use an arm to put them over the top.
Heavy weights like the Yankees, Angels, Red Sox and Dodgers (divorce not withstanding) all have pitching issues. Acquiring an ace would give the team a nice jolt of adrenaline.
It will change the entire complexion of the pennant race if and when these deals are made… and make me feel not as bad for making lousy predictions in April!
Sully Baseball 